Which one is better for acne scars? Murad Age Spot Pigment Lightening gel or Post-Acne Spot Lightening Gel?

I'm 17 years old (female)Which one is better for acne scars? Murad Age Spot Pigment Lightening gel or Post-Acne Spot Lightening Gel?
Vitamin E oil and it makes your face really greasy but I promise results. I've worn it to bed for the past 6 months and my scars have gone about 50%. Just use a good wash in the mornings like clean %26amp; clear continuous and they have the advantage moisturizer. I use oil blotter cloths too so I don't have to wash my face too much. I've never tried either of those.